8 May 2020

3 minute read

North America

Reporting from Reuters finds that farmers in the US and Canada have nowhere to ship their cattle, following shuttered slaughterhouses and the moribund food service sector.

Previous reporting from Reuters has shown that fast-food chain Wendy's is running out of beef, while Kroger and Costco limit sales of some meat items, underlining the growing dislocation in the meat supply chain.

Canada and the United States are among the world's biggest beef exporters, but outbreaks have forced plants owned by Cargill Inc, JBS SA and Tyson Foods to temporarily close or slow production, as they balance worker safety with food security.

"It’s a horrible situation for us to watch," said Leighton Kolk, who normally ships 500 head of cattle to slaughter per week from his feedlot at Iron Springs, Alberta.

Last week, he moved 40 and is not sure there will be a single bid this week, at a time when he normally sees the highest prices of the year ahead of barbecue season. Each head of cattle that stays on his farm costs $4 CAD per day to feed.

"The consumer is going to pay a huge price and we could approach financial insolvency because these animals are dropping in value," Kolk said.

Ryan Kasko, chairman of the Alberta Cattle Feeders' Association, estimates there are up to 80,000 Canadian cattle awaiting slaughter, and the number may reach 250,000 head by July.

"A month ago, I couldn't even imagine this," Kasko, a feedlot operator, said.

But beef buyers are seeing anything but glut conditions.

"From time to time, there could be some items that we're out of stock on," Wendys Chief Executive Todd Penegor told analysts on Wednesday. "It's probably a couple of weeks of challenging tightness that we'll have to work through."

Victor Colello, director of meat and fish at New York City grocery chain Morton Williams, said he has not had any trouble getting meat but that "prices are crazy."

"In the past two weeks, prices have gone up anywhere from $3 to $5 per pound. I find myself changing prices every two or three days."

"I'm 56 years old, I've been doing this all my life and I've never experienced something like this," Colello said.

Beef prices are jumping higher

The average unit price of fresh beef at US tracked retailers was 6 percent higher in the week ended 25 April than a year earlier, according to market research firm Nielsen.

Those prices are not reaching cattle farmers, however. Some packers offer no bids for cattle, while others offered prices that were 30 percent lower from January, Kasko said.

With packers offering low prices for cattle and meat prices high in stores, 11 Midwestern states on Tuesday urged the federal Department of Justice to investigate suspected price fixing by meat packers.

Kolk and Kasko normally ship to two Alberta plants that together supply two-thirds of Canada's beef, but are now coronavirus hotspots.

Cargill resumed production this week at High River, Alberta after a two-week shutdown, and JBS is producing more slowly at its Brooks, Alberta plant.

Tyson Foods has shuttered cattle slaughterhouses in Dakota City, Nebraska, and in Pasco, Washington, which partially reopened on Tuesday. US President Donald Trump has ordered meat processors to keep plants open.

Canada and the United States have both announced aid packages for the food and agriculture sectors.

Alberta rancher Kelly Smith-Fraser sees a long crisis ahead.

Price estimates for the calves she will sell in autumn are less than half of the usual price, as the feedlots who buy them cope with big cattle backlogs.

"Each day we are on pins and needles to make sure those plants stay open."

Read the full analysis from Reuters.